Yes, you can sometimes refinance a home that is worth less than you owe in Arizona. But a regular refinance will not work, because lenders need equity to approve one. The path depends on the loan you already have. If it is FHA or VA, you may have an easy route. If it is conventional, your options are narrower and you may need to bring cash. Here is how to figure out which situation you are in, with real numbers from Metro Phoenix.

What underwater actually means

You are underwater when your mortgage balance is higher than what the house would sell for today. Say you bought in Scottsdale or Phoenix in 2022 near the peak, put down 10%, and owe $480,000. If your home would appraise at $450,000 now, you owe $30,000 more than it is worth. Your loan to value ratio is about 107%.

Prices in parts of the Valley have softened, especially in condos and in newer subdivisions where builders cut prices. Our post on Phoenix condo prices at a three year low shows where it is worst. Most owners are not underwater. If you bought before 2021 or put down 20% or more, you very likely still have equity. Check before you worry. Look at recent sales on your street, and read our guide on how much equity you need to refinance.

Underwater is a math problem, not a verdict. Your loan type decides how hard it is.

Your options, by loan type

Each route has its own rules. This table gives the short version. Details change by lender, so treat it as a map.

The old federal program that let underwater owners refinance, HARP, ended in 2018. Some lenders now offer newer high loan to value options for conventional loans, which we cover in our post on ReFi Possible and similar programs in Arizona. Not every borrower qualifies, and lenders set their own overlays, which is why asking more than one matters.

The easy routes: FHA and VA

If your loan is FHA, a streamline refinance can lower your rate without a new appraisal. That means your home value does not block you. You still need on time payments and a real benefit, such as a lower payment. Read the full rules in our guide to the FHA streamline refinance in Arizona, and see the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's FHA loan page for program basics.

VA borrowers have the same advantage. An interest rate reduction refinance does not need an appraisal either. Details are in our post on the VA streamline refinance. Here is the catch for both: a streamline only makes sense if today's rates beat yours. Freddie Mac's survey had the 30-year fixed at 7.40% on October 8, so if you locked in 2022 or 2023 at a rate near 6%, a streamline would raise your payment, not lower it.

Run your own numbers

The cash in route, with numbers

If your loan is conventional and you want to refinance, the usual answer is to bring cash. The lender picks a maximum loan to value, and you pay down the balance until you hit it. On the $480,000 balance and $450,000 value above, here is what that looks like.

That is a lot of money to put into a house that lost value. Do it only if the refinance itself earns the money back, for example by escaping an adjustable rate that is about to reset. Our post on the cash in refinance walks through the break-even math, and a mortgage recast can lower your payment after a big principal payment without a new loan, if your lender allows it.

Before you spend a dollar, get a real value, not a guess. Online estimates can miss by tens of thousands in a market where prices are moving. Ask a local agent for a comparable sales review, or order your own appraisal if a lender will use it. If the true value comes in higher than you feared, you may be closer to a normal refinance than you thought. A five percent difference on a $450,000 home is $22,500, which can change the cash you need by that much. Also check whether you paid mortgage insurance on a low down payment. Once your balance falls to 80% of the original value, or your home value rises, you may be able to drop it without refinancing at all. Ask your servicer what their process is, because it varies.

When waiting is the smart move

If your rate is fixed and below today's market, you are not losing anything by staying put. You keep paying, your balance falls, and values in most of Maricopa County have recovered from dips before. Waiting costs nothing, and refinancing at 7.40% to chase a problem you can solve by time makes little sense. The bigger risk is an adjustable rate that resets, a balloon, or a job change that forces a sale. In those cases talk to a lender sooner, not later. Our post on anti-deficiency protection in Arizona explains how state law treats a loan if things go wrong, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's home owner resources explain your rights if you are falling behind.

Shop more than one lender

Underwater rules vary from lender to lender, so an answer from one bank does not apply everywhere. A broker can ask several at once, which you can see on our loan programs page, and our process shows how we do it. If you decide to sell instead, browse what is available in your price range on Arizona Luxury Property Search. Get your numbers ready first: current balance, interest rate, loan type, monthly payment, and a rough value from recent sales within a half mile.

Meet the Pillar Mortgage Group team, see more at pillarmortgagegroup.com, then book a call or use the form below.

Frequently asked questions